Free Shipping on orders of $75 or more in Ontario and Quebec. Discounted shipping for all other provinces on orders of $75 or more.

Puckerbutt Carolina Reaper Mash

Heat Chart


From the creator of the Carolina Reaper pepper comes an all natural mash of the world's hottest pepper.

Ingredients: Carolina Reaper Peppers, Vinegar

Manufactured by Puckerbutt Pepper Company

Next Previous

Customer Reviews

Based on 4 reviews

didnt try yet

Ingredient, not sauce.

This is not a sauce, it is an additive, a precursor or an ingredient. Spicy pickles, 2 cups vinegar, 1 cup sugar, 1/4 teaspoon mash, diluted and mixed, add 1 thinly or thickly depending on opinion, sliced cucumber to mixture, let sit and brine for 24 hours. Just don't call it a sauce.

Hallelujah! I have been searching

Hallelujah! I have been searching for the perfect HOT sauce. Our family has a tradition of trying hot sauces at Xmas time.....the Hot Sauce Challenge. But have fallen short even as I scour the world literally. I have a Mexican son-in-law ya! So this beauty is going to kick butt. I did try it before our family get toget her and I think I have an ultimate winner here! Thx for your awesome service in caring about mailing it in the cold! I will be ordering more from you!

Extreme heat AND flavour. I

Extreme heat AND flavour. I will buy again.

Related Items

Heat Chart
Heat Chart
★ Reviews

Let customers speak for us

2478 reviews
Horrible after taste

This sauce gets two stars from me due to the horrible after taste but contains a crazy amount of heat. It feels hotter than some other sauces I have that are rated much higher in scovilles. I only bought this due to the "hot ones" show to see what the fuss was about. I think it was a mistake to add "natural pepper flavoring", tomato paste and some wrong spices that contribute to an icky after taste (not talking about heat).


I stayed away from this sauce for a while but after watching "hot ones" my curiosity was peaked. I didn't find it as hot as some of the others that were rated lower in scoville units in their show line up. For the level of heat, I echo the comments already made. The makers of this sauce did an incredible job balancing heat with sharp flavors such as sun dried tomatoes needed to poke through. Love this sauce.

OMG The ingredients

The stuff they squeeze into this little bottle, likely why it costs a lot more. I agree with the others that this isn't super crazy hot given the types of peppers used. The makers did a good job mixing it all together in the right combination. This goes great with wild game meats, thanksgiving and other festive turkey meals. But i don't really think there's anything this hot sauce doesn't taste good with.


My head tolerance is a bit low but this sauce is absolutely perfect. Perhaps not as hot as the heat scale given in the product description though. This sauce won with over with a disclaimer that the sour cherry may contain pits. That's awesome and screams no fake simulated cherry powered in this sauce. Will be buying this again.

Disguisting and disapointing.

I'm not a hot sauce expert but my taste buds hate this rub. For a long time, I've been looking for a cherry power spice. I tried to make my own using dollar store simulated cherry powder and this Mary's product is far worse. Imagine a no name cherry coke, add a ton more sugar, a while the smoke tries to overpower the similar tart cherry flavor that actually gives me a headache. To their credit, if real dehydrated cherry powder was used, they would likely have to charge around $30/shaker. I would pay this if they added some heat to this... otherwise cook your stuff in dr. pepper or cherry coke and save money. Won't be buying this again.